Learning from Experience
When I started dating my wife, I learned an uncomfortable truth: not everyone would be happy for me. Sometimes, a toxic friend rears their ugly head, aiming to cause chaos in your relationship. I remember the moment clearly—it was a casual Saturday dinner with her friends. While I thought we were all getting along, one friend, let’s call her “Emily,” kept dropping passive-aggressive comments about how much time my wife and I were spending together.
“Oh, I guess we’ll never see you again,” she said, with that tight-lipped smile that only hinted at how much she really meant it.
At first, I brushed it off. But over the next few months, Emily’s jabs turned sharper, and her energy more draining. My wife, to her credit, tried to keep the peace.
“She’s just adjusting,” she said.
But I could see the toll it was taking on her. The constant drama, the backhanded remarks, the guilt trips—it was exhausting. Slowly but surely, Emily faded from the picture, and you know what? My wife was happier for it.
This experience taught me two things: first, a truly healthy relationship often reveals who’s in your corner—and who isn’t. Second, as men, it’s important to help our girlfriends navigate these changes, especially when a “friend” is more toxic than supportive.
Why Does A Toxic Friend Do This?
When women enter a healthy, fulfilling relationship, it can challenge the dynamics of their existing friendships. Research published in Psychology Today explains that friendships often operate within the context of shared experiences and priorities. If your girlfriend is prioritizing her relationship (which is natural and healthy), some friends might feel threatened. They can then transform into a toxic friend.
Unfortunately, not all friends want what’s best for her. Just as a crazy girlfriend can destroy your relationship, toxic friends often thrive on dependency, drama, or control. A healthy relationship disrupts that balance, exposing who’s genuinely supportive and who’s only there for the dysfunction.
A 2022 study from the University of Kansas found that women in long-term, stable relationships reported a reduction in their social circles by 2-3 people, on average. Interestingly, most of the lost connections were described as “draining” or “negative.” It’s not a coincidence. Growth and commitment have a way of weeding out the people who weren’t really rooting for you.
Behaviors of a Toxic Friend
You may be wondering if you’re being paranoid or if you’re actually up against some toxic “friends”. Get familiar with this list of red flags so you can come to that conclusion as fast as possible.
- Jealousy Disguised as Jokes – “I guess we’ll never see you again!” is just guilt in a cute outfit. Constant passive-aggressive remarks about her success, relationship, or happiness.
- Sabotaging Behavior – Encouraging reckless decisions, belittling her choices, or spreading rumors behind her back. A real friend protects her, not sets her up for failure.
- Constant Negativity – Always complaining, gossiping, or playing the victim. They drain her emotionally instead of building her up.
- Competitive, Not Supportive – Instead of celebrating her wins, they try to one-up her. If everything turns into a comparison, it’s a competition, not a friendship.
- Lack of Reciprocity – If she’s always the one reaching out, making plans, and offering emotional support, but never receiving the same effort in return, it’s a one-sided friendship.
- Plays the Victim, Never Takes Accountability – They always have drama, and somehow, it’s never their fault. Every conflict is someone else’s doing, including hers.
- Guilt-Tripping and Manipulation – Making her feel bad for setting boundaries, having other friends, or focusing on personal growth. Phrases like “Wow, you’ve changed” are often just disguised control tactics.
- Talks About Others Behind Their Back – If they constantly trash-talk mutual friends, chances are they do the same to her when she’s not around.
- Doesn’t Respect Her Boundaries – Pressuring her into things she’s not comfortable with, dismissing her needs, or making her feel bad for saying “no.”
- Only Around When They Need Something – They disappear when things are good but suddenly reappear when they need help, money, or a favor.
- Overly Possessive or Controlling – Gets upset when she spends time with other friends or makes choices without consulting them first. A good friend wants her to have a full, healthy life outside of the friendship.
- Demeaning “Advice” Disguised as Concern – “I mean, if you’re happy dating him, I guess that’s all that matters.” Instead of being supportive, they undermine her choices and confidence.
How to Handle It as a Man
It’s tempting to jump in and “fix” things when you notice a toxic friend, but this is her battle to fight. Here’s how you can be supportive without overstepping:
1. Be her safe space: Let her vent without trying to “solve” the issue immediately. Sometimes, she just needs to talk it through.
2. Point out patterns gently: “Have you noticed how Emily’s comments make you feel after you hang out?” A nudge, not a shove.
3. Encourage self-respect: Help her see that she deserves friends who celebrate her happiness, not resent it.
4. Avoid ultimatums: Don’t make it about you vs. her friends. Let her come to her own conclusions.
Toxic friendships can be just as damaging as toxic relationships. Real friends want to see her win, not subtly sabotage her success. 🚩
-Your Big Bro
For more perspectives on dating, subscribe to our free newsletter “Weekly Bro Chat” on Substack.
